Do I Need More Wi-Fi Access Points – or Better Wi-Fi Design?

It’s a common misconception that poor Wi-Fi is caused by not having enough Access Points.

Unfortunately, businesses often assume that the solution to dead spots or unreliable connections is to buy another AP. Of course, there are occasions where it might work – But there are also times when adding another AP could make an existing Wi-Fi problem worse.

It’s important to remember that Wi-Fi performance is about coverage, capacity and RF design, not just the number of Access Points. 

A specially designed network determines:

  • Where AP’s should be located
  • How they should be configured
  • How they interact

The aim isn’t just to have maximum signal everywhere – It’s to have a predictable, reliable wireless network. And that is where professional Wi-Fi engineers like the team here at Geekabit can help get your network working at its optimum for your business. 

What Does a Wi-Fi Access Point Actually Do?

What is an Access Point? 

An Access Point is a networking hardware device that helps create a wireless local area network, for example in an office or business premises. The wireless local area network (WLAN) is a computer network that connects devices together using radio waves instead of physical cables. 

What does an Access Point do?

The Access Point connects wireless devices to a wired local network.  

An Access Point bridges networks by plugging into a wired router or switch using an Ethernet cable and translates that wired data into a Wi-Fi signal.

They extend coverage by creating a wireless zone in areas where the main router’s Wi-Fi signal cannot reach.

Access Points act as a central hub, letting phones, laptops, and smart devices connect to the network at the same time without losing speed or stability.

They support high capacity in locations like large offices or schools. Multiple Access Points work together to handle hundreds or even thousands of users depending on the size of the venue and network. 

AP’s in Business Networks

Business networks commonly have multiple AP’s working together. Devices move between AP coverage areas and need to be able to roam appropriately. 

AP’s share a finite radio spectrum with neighbouring AP’s and other devices. This means that simply installing more AP’s doesn’t automatically provide more usable Wi-Fi. 

  • Business networks commonly have multiple APs working together.
  • Devices move between AP coverage areas and need to roam appropriately.
  • AP’s share a finite radio spectrum with neighbouring APs and other devices.
  • Therefore, simply installing more APs doesn’t automatically provide more usable Wi-Fi.

How Many Wi-Fi Access Points Does a Business Need?

Wouldn’t it be lovely if there was a reliable formula based purely on square metres? Unfortunately there isn’t, it doesn’t work like that.

The number of Access Points that a business needs depends on:

  • Building size.
  • Building materials.
  • Floor layout.
  • Number of floors.
  • Number of users/devices.
  • Types of devices.
  • Applications being used.
  • Required speeds.
  • Voice/video requirements.
  • Existing neighbouring Wi-Fi networks.
  • Available wired network infrastructure.

It makes sense that different businesses in different industries with different Wi-Fi needs – Think warehouse, hotel, office, school – would need different Wi-Fi designs, despite having identical floor area on paper. 

You also need to bear in mind that capacity can require additional AP’s even where signal coverage is already excellent.

What Are the Signs That I Might Need Another Access Point?

There will of course be scenarios where another Access Point would be a legitimate Wi-Fi fix. So how do you as a business recognise when you might need another Access Point?

  • Identifying an area with genuinely inadequate usable coverage.
  • Getting poor signal in rooms separated by substantial walls
  • Requiring coverage across additional floors
  • Realising some outdoor areas need Wi-Fi
  • Having high numbers of devices concentrated in particular locations (high density areas)
  • Noticing users experiencing poor performance only in particular physical areas
  • Having an existing AP physically incapable of providing appropriate coverage

Whilst these scenarios may well benefit from another strategically placed AP, it’s worth saying that these symptoms justify investigation. Investing in a well designed Wi-Fi network could mean you don’t waste money on unnecessary APs. 

Can You Have Too Many Wi-Fi Access Points?

Simply – Yes! It is possible that having too many Access Points can cause more problems and make your WI-Fi worse rather than better. 

APs share available radio spectrum. This means it’s possible that there could be co-channel interference or contention between APs. This is when more than one AP uses the exact same frequency channel at the same time, in an overlapping area. 

Having too many Access Points can also cause Adjacent-channel interference where a transmission on one frequency leaks into a neighboring, overlapping frequency channel causing signal distortion.

Too many APs in one area causes excessive overlapping coverage.

Strategic channel selection helps your APs work to their most effective. Poor channel selection causes signal interference, slower speeds, and dropped connections.

Transmit power is also a strategic choice. You might think you should just set the AP to maximum power to get the best performance, however excessive transmit power can mean that APs are connecting to wireless devices inappropriately, when devices should roam and connect to a better placed AP that will provide a more reliable connection. Just because an AP is ‘shouting louder’ doesn’t mean it can provide the best connection. 

Unfortunately, excellent-looking signal bars don’t always translate to efficient wireless networks and often exhibit disappointing real world performance. Dense installations should always be properly planned and installed.

Why Full Wi-Fi Signal Doesn’t Necessarily Mean Good Wi-Fi

Signal strength is only one measurement, and can be affected by various factors between the AP and the device. 

We can scrutinise wireless signal in a few different ways. 

  • RSSI (Received Signal Strength Indicator) is a measurement of how strong a wireless signal is when a device receives it. RSSI is usually shown as a negative number in decibels-milliwatts (dBm) and a value closer to 0 means a stronger signal.
  • SNR (Signal to Noise Ratio) is the ratio comparing the power of a desired useful signal to the power of unwanted background noise, usually measured in decibels (dB). A higher SNR means a clear, crisp signal with very little interference. A low SNR means the signal is hidden or corrupted by static and noise.
  • Noise and interference are unwanted radio signals or physical blocks that disrupt your wireless connection and slow down your internet.
  • Channel utilization is the percentage of time that a specific wireless channel is busy transmitting or receiving data, or blocked by interference. In Wi-Fi, only one device can talk on a channel at an exact millisecond, so a busy channel forces other devices to wait. This in turn lowers overall network speed and increases lag.
  • Regarding wireless connectivity, airtime refers to the actual duration an Access Point or client spends actively communicating data across a specific frequency.

A device can show full bars while experiencing:

  • Slow downloads.
  • High latency.
  • Teams/Zoom problems.
  • Dropouts.
  • Poor roaming.

Remember, Wi-Fi is two-way communication. The AP must hear the client as well as the client hearing the AP.

Access Point Placement Matters as Much as Access Point Quantity

An AP shouldn’t simply be installed wherever an Ethernet cable happens to be available.

Here are some of the poor locations our Wi-Fi engineers have discovered APs when investigating a poorly performing Wi-Fi network:

  • Cupboards.
  • Behind televisions/screens.
  • Inside cabinets.
  • Above inappropriate building materials.
  • At one end of a building.

Hiding APs away in cupboards aren’t the only things that can cause a wireless network to perform badly. Walls, concrete, metal, glass and building layout all affect RF differently too.

Ensuring the correct placement of Access Points can sometimes reduce the number of APs required.

Professional Wi-Fi network planning considers both coverage and capacity.

What Is Professional Wi-Fi Design?

The best Wi-Fi design starts with requirements rather than equipment.

When we investigate an office or business premises for a new or updated Wi-Fi network, our Wi-Fi engineers always determine:

  • Where Wi-Fi is required.
  • Number/ type of clients.
  • Critical applications.
  • Performance requirements.
  • Physical environment.

Our engineers do this by carrying out an appropriate survey which can include:

  • Predictive modelling.
  • On-site measurements.
  • Spectrum/RF analysis.
  • Validation after installation.

AP locations, channels, channel widths and power settings can then be designed accordingly, meaning your Wi-Fi network actually matches your business needs.

Don’t Forget the Wired Network

Wi-Fi networks aren’t always just about the wireless element – There is also a wired component. The Wi-Fi Access Point ultimately connects to Ethernet. This means that problems with a Wi-Fi network could potentially originate in a wired part of the network, including:

  • Damaged cabling.
  • 100 Mbps links where Gigabit was expected.
  • Faulty termination.
  • Switch problems.
  • Insufficient PoE.
  • VLAN/configuration problems.
  • Router/firewall problems.
  • Internet connection itself.

Just blindly installing another AP won’t fix an underlying wired-network fault.

Should I Add Another AP or Get a Wi-Fi Survey?

If the cause of your Wi-Fi problems isn’t obvious, then it’s a good idea to diagnose the issue before purchasing more equipment.

A Wi-Fi Site Survey can identify:

  • Coverage gaps.
  • Interference.
  • AP placement problems.
  • Channel problems.
  • Capacity issues.
  • Cabling/ network issues.

Sometimes recommendations may genuinely be another AP! 

Other times, your existing equipment ends up being able to perform much better simply through a redesign or  reconfiguration.

Our approach here at Geekabit is always to diagnose the Wi-Fi problem first, and then prescribe the solution second.

How Geekabit Can Help

Here at Geekabit, our Wi-Fi engineers have specialist Wi-Fi and networking expertise rather than just generic IT support. Think of it as a GP referring you to a specialist consultant.

We can help with:

  • Business Wi-Fi troubleshooting.
  • Wi-Fi health checks.
  • Wireless surveys.
  • RF planning and design.
  • Network testing.
  • Existing network optimisation.
  • New installations and upgrades.

It’s always worth discussing and investigating unreliable Wi-Fi before buying more equipment.

Our expert Wi-Fi engineers are based in Hampshire and carry out work for local businesses as well as London and UK projects as appropriate. Get in touch with our team here. 

FAQs

Can adding more access points make Wi-Fi worse?

  • Yes.
  • Poorly planned APs can increase contention/interference.
  • Correct channels, power, placement and channel widths matter.
  • More APs should be deployed as part of a design.

How many Wi-Fi access points do I need per square metre?

  • No universally reliable ratio.
  • Depends on construction, layout, users, applications and RF environment.
  • Capacity can be as important as coverage.

Why is my Wi-Fi slow when I have full signal?

  • Signal strength isn’t the same as connection quality.
  • Could be congestion, interference, retries, network problems or internet issues.

Should every room have its own Wi-Fi access point?

  • Not necessarily.
  • Some environments benefit from room-level APs.
  • In others it creates unnecessary density.
  • Requirements should determine design.

How far apart should Wi-Fi access points be?

  • No universal distance.
  • Building construction and RF conditions significantly affect propagation.
  • Placement should be based on required coverage and capacity.

Will a Wi-Fi survey tell me where to put access points?

  • Yes, that can be one of the key outcomes.
  • Can also identify configuration and RF problems with existing deployments.
How Does My Device Connect to Wi-Fi Access Points?

Have you ever wondered how your device connects to an Access Point? If you’ve got strong Wi-Fi and broadband, then connecting your device to a network can feel instant. But there are actually several states and sequences that a device and Access Point need to work through in order for you to connect and be able to send and receive data. 

What is an Access Point?

An Access Point, or AP, is a bridge that bridges traffic between mobile stations (for example, laptops, tablets, smartphones) and other devices on a network. Before a mobile station can send data traffic through an AP, it must be in an appropriate connection state. There are three 802.11 connection states. 

These connection states are:

  • Not authenticated or associated
  • Authenticated but not yet associated.
  • Authenticated and associated. 

For bridging to occur, a mobile station must be in an authenticated and associated state.

In order to get to an authenticated and associated state, the mobile station and AP will exchange a series of 802.11 management frames.

802.11 Management Frames

A mobile station (for example your laptop, smartphone or tablet) always starts out as not authenticated and associated.

Probe Request

  • The mobile station will send a Probe Request to discover 802.11 networks within its proximity. 
  • A Probe Request advertises the mobile stations supported data rates and 802.11 capabilities, for example 802.11n. 
  • The Probe Request is sent from the mobile station to the destination layer-2 address and BSSID of ff:ff:ff:ff:ff:ff resulting in all AP’s that receive the request to respond.

Probe Response

  • APs receiving the Probe Request check to see if the mobile station has at least one common supported data rate.
  • If they have compatible data rates, a probe response is sent advertising the SSID (wireless network name), supported data rates, encryption types if required, and other 802.11 capabilities of the AP. 
  •  A mobile station chooses compatible networks from the Probe Responses it receives. Compatibility could be based on encryption type. 
  • Once compatible networks are discovered the mobile station will attempt low-level 802.11 authentication with compatible APs. 

Keep in mind that 802.11 authentication is not the same as WPA2 or 802.1X authentication mechanisms which occur after a mobile station is authenticated and associated. Originally 802.11 authentication frames were designed for WEP encryption however this security scheme has been proven to be insecure and therefore deprecated. Because of this 802.11 authentication frames are open and almost always succeed. 

Authentication Open Sequence 1

  • A mobile station sends a low-level 802.11 Authentication frame to an AP setting the authentication to open and the sequence to 0x0001.

Authentication Open Sequence 2

  • The AP receives the Authentication frame and responds to the mobile station with authentication frame set to open indicating a sequence of 0x0002.
  • If an AP receives any frame other than an Authentication or Probe Request from a mobile station that is not authenticated it will respond with a deauthentication frame placing the mobile into an unauthenticated and unassociated state. 
  • The station will have to begin the Association process from the low level authentication step. At this point the mobile station is authenticated but not yet associated. 
  • Some 802.11 capabilities allow a mobile station to low-level authenticate to multiple APs. This speeds up the Association process when moving between APs. A mobile station can be 802.11 authenticated to multiple APs however it can only be actively associated and transferring data through a single AP at a time.  

Association Request

  • A mobile station will send an Association request to the AP that it has determined it would like to associate to. 
  • The Association request contains chosen encryption types if required and other compatible 802.11 capabilities. 
  • If an AP receives a frame from a mobile station that is authenticated but not yet associated, it will respond with a disassociation frame placing the mobile into an authenticated but unassociated state. 

Association Response

  • If the elements in the Association request match the capabilities of the AP, the AP will create an Association ID for the mobile station and respond with an association response with a success message granting network access to the mobile station.  

Data Transfer

  • The mobile station is now successfully associated to the AP and data transfer can begin.

It’s worth noting that if WPA/WPA2 or 802.1X authentication is required on the wireless network, the mobile station will not be able to send data until dynamic keying and authentication have taken place after the 802.11 Association is complete.